Gamasutra: Max Samorukov’s Blog – How To Evaluate Mobile Game Ideas

The next weblog publish, except in any other case famous, was written by a member of Gamasutra’s group.
The ideas and opinions expressed are these of the author and never Gamasutra or its dad or mum firm.


For the younger (and in any other case) builders keen about an concept of a selected sport

Here’s a query sport builders typically discover themselves involved with: how do I consider the viability of a sport concept that I’m about to start out engaged on? Having invested many months and a ton of different sources in growth, you’d fairly like to finish up with a sport that’s not simply enjoyable to play with your mates, however is an precise technique of getting cash. 

A fast statistical perception: every month, a median of 10,000 new video games seem within the cellular shops* that might be ranked no less than as soon as, even within the least outstanding class; in no less than one nation; for no less than sooner or later. That’s, all these apps get no less than a speck of limelight as they make the radar—gaining a pair hundreds of downloads, incomes a number of hundred {dollars}. About two thirds of them appear like builders have put plenty of effort into manufacturing: they’ve coherent gameplay, artwork, UI, and so forth. The implication is that the devs labored laborious, had acceptable abilities and have been keen about one specific concept.

And but, solely round 3% of those will earn greater than $100,000 over their lifetime. What concerning the others then? These builders will need to have had sure aspirations and conviction, believing of their concept’s potential identical to the extra profitable ones. Alas, it didn’t work out. 

So, what are you able to do? How do you improve the possibilities of your future sport’s business success? In reality, there are some things to have a look at in an effort to work out the business potential.

It’s not uncommon for us to play some sport after which change into taken by the thought of making your personal model of it. For instance, one thing just like Archero or Brawl Stars. Ever occurred to you? Earlier than getting elbows deep into growth, it’s value checking if anybody has already had the same concept. And, if sure, what has come of their efforts?

There are a number of methods to seek out apps of comparable nature: 

  • Search cellular shops by key phrases. For Google Play, this works fairly properly. For instance, for the Archero talked about earlier, the outcomes are good. Nevertheless, this technique is not going to work for all of the video games: its effectivity relies on the best way the actual retailer ranks its search outcomes and on the competitors for the used phrase. 

  • Search by subgenre. You’ll discover this feature supplied by AppAnnie (however it’s paid and really costly), GameIntel (without spending a dime, you’ll be able to see the highest 5 apps by subgenre based mostly on the highest free app within the USA) and AppMagic (free, no limitations). 

After researching and making an intensive record of essentially the most related titles out of your goal subgenre, you’ll be able to consider how particular your concept is; which sport design, monetization, artwork and UI options seem like linked with success; and whether or not or not you’ll be able to create a product which will be, with sure conviction, put in keeping with essentially the most profitable references discovered.

It is very important needless to say trying to find reference apps solely within the charts’ prime ranks might lead to survivorship bias. That’s the reason it is very important take note of the much less profitable apps simply as nicely. Digging deeper into the shops is the way you uncover tens of millions of inglorious improvements resting (in peace or else).

The sort of evaluation received’t provide help to discover assured concepts for a profitable sport, however it may assist keep away from expensive errors by leveraging different builders’ experience.

This strategy to growth typically works out relatively properly, however it’s nonetheless necessary to investigate others’ errors earlier than embarking by yourself growth journey. 

Let’s persist with the thought of constructing your personal variation on Archero for now.









Take a look at Archero’s month-to-month income proven in opposition to 18 of its most outstanding clones. Sure, Archero’s personal income is the blue space of the stacked graph, whereas the skinny multi-color line is the aggregated revenue of all of its clones. Spectacular, proper? Every of the builders of those video games most likely had a imaginative and prescient: they tried bringing one thing distinctive and thrilling to the sport in hopes of securing success; they put in plenty of effort. And but none managed to even come shut. 

Furthermore, the unique Archero’s income has been falling from simply concerning the very starting. What does it inform us? Most of all, that growing the sport on this style is a harmful problem. The graph doesn’t inform us why precisely not one of the Archero clones succeeded, however it demonstrates the concepts and variations which were exploited and couldn’t do the trick, thus warning you in opposition to another person’s tried and examined errors and serving to save loads of your time, cash and stress. 

Visualizations of the kind above can be found to AppMagic’s premium customers and are a helpful means of evaluating a number of apps’ revenues in a single graph. Nevertheless, you’ll be able to nonetheless use AppMagic’s free instruments to check the positions of video games in prime grossing charts over time.

It is very important do not forget that solely income from funds, subscriptions, and paid installations decide a sport’s place in prime grossing charts. Promoting income can’t be detected, and there’s no analytical service that may give you decently correct estimates of promoting revenues for cellular functions. Nevertheless, some perception into promoting revenues will be gleaned from analyzing how app downloads are distributed throughout international locations. This knowledge is on the market without spending a dime from AppMagic. 





Promoting income from a person from international locations like India and Vietnam, if the monetization is configured correctly, is $0.01-$0.05 cents (relying on retention, viewers and sport monetization); for Russia and Brazil, it’s 3 to five instances greater. Promoting income from the wealthiest international locations can attain $1-2 per person. 

In different phrases, should you see a sport with a excessive variety of downloads, you should definitely establish the important thing international locations the place the majority of its site visitors comes from. If many of the contribution arrives from international locations with low GDP per capita, akin to India, Cambodia or Brazil, then one mustn’t depend on excessive advert income: from 1,000,000 downloads in India, chances are you’ll earn simply $10-20K tops.

To sum up, if you end up fascinated by growing a variation on an current sport, right here’s some recommendation: should you really wish to make some money versus simply spend time growing the product, give extra thought to revolutionary options in monetization, person retention and speculation testing relatively than to lovely artwork and twists in core gameplay. 

If we have a look at how income shares of various cellular sport genres have been altering within the largest Western international locations, the very first thing we discover is a pointy lower within the pink space that stands for RTS video games.

In cellular video games, there are not any conventional RTS titles as we all know them from PCs; within the cellular context, an RTS is normally a PvP sport with real-time battles and parts of technique the place you’re required to manage many items, akin to Conflict of Clans or Island Conflict.

The query is, “Why have video games of this style been shedding their market share so quick?” Are there possibly no newcomers on this style? However there are! Are they of poor high quality? Nope: there are many nice video games. So what’s going on? 

When one thing (a sport or a style—RTS is simply an instance right here) isn’t rising or shrinking, the reason being all the time the identical: builders can not purchase sufficient site visitors to develop with a constructive ROMI (return on advertising and marketing funding). Within the case of a style, it implies that video games of different genres with the identical audience will pay significantly extra for an set up, which leads to them claiming site visitors. 

It is very important perceive that, with the scaling of person acquisition and different issues being equal, the price of one set up is growing. Thus, a sport (or style) with a better LTV (Lifetime Worth) in comparison with its rivals is not going to declare the entire site visitors, however the stability will shift: the one who is able to pay extra per set up will get extra site visitors.The flip aspect is that even video games with low LTVs can nonetheless buy some customers; nonetheless, the determine is usually so low that it would not justify the prices of sustaining the sport and the advertising and marketing staff.

Seeing the speed at which the share of RTS video games has been falling, it’s clear that this style is presently shedding its battle for site visitors on cellular platforms. And which means this can be very harmful to start out growing a sport of this style.

One factor so as to add is that revolutions occur in lots of genres every now and then, unlocking nice alternatives for entire new generations of video games. That’s the reason it is very important maintain observe of profitable new merchandise in several genres should you do not wish to miss your window of alternative.

How are you going to observe profitable new arrivals? For this objective, some corporations present particular instruments for monitoring just lately launched and fast-growing apps, together with GameIntel (you’ll be able to see 5 apps of the subgenre without spending a dime within the prime free apps chart within the USA) and AppMagic (free, no limitations).

To hell together with your advertising and marketing! True avid gamers will probability upon my sport and adore it and inform all their buddies and the shops will assist an excellent sport with site visitors—that’s the way it’s gonna work! 

Erm, no. That’s not how the cellular market works. There may be nearly no free site visitors within the shops. And what’s accessible is not going to give you the chance to earn cash. Sure, there are a few exceptions: one being featured on a non-contractual foundation and the opposite—utilizing referral site visitors from shops. However you can’t issue them in as your key methods to earn money.

Sure, there are examples of video games in shops which have change into tremendous viral and bought caught firmly in prime charts whereas, on the similar time, by no means shopping for site visitors (or shopping for little or no of it). Nevertheless, these tales, for essentially the most half, date again to previous instances when there have been nonetheless many empty niches out there—for instance, equivalent to conventional video games (card, sports activities, board). We will additionally recall unicums akin to Minecraft and Roblox, however do keep in mind: these are these very hanging uncommon exceptions from the final rule. 

What do you do if you’re not but accustomed to how person acquisition works? On this case, earlier than beginning your growth, guarantee that the market** is rising or is no less than secure, and that its leaders change every now and then, making means for brand new titles. As soon as the app is produced, discover a accomplice that understands the right way to flip an bold sport right into a blockbuster: a writer with a file of notable current success, or a site visitors company with good references from buddies.


* Refers back to the largest cellular shops: Apple App Retailer and Google Play Retailer

** Refers to style or subgenre